11e. Next Critique off an enthusiastic Empirical Blog post
A feedback of an empirical post examines the effectiveness of the new empirical proof supporting the author’s conflict. Each other strengths and weaknesses can be known in the a feedback. Define and justify all of your complaints affairs inside the at the very least 3-4 sentences.
step one. CLARITY: Is the article’s objective and you may argument clear? Perform some boffins certainly develop a primary research question, proposal, otherwise theory that’ll be examined on the empirical data and you may discussed in this article? In case the data try exploratory (preliminary), is sufficient justification for an exploratory approach considering?
2. Theoretical GROUNDING: ‘s the researcher’s dispute rooted much more basic principle? Could it possibly be obvious if the framework of your own empirical study (we.age., their work) is based on theory, or maybe just made-up? (more…)